davideisinger.com

My personal website
Log | Files | Refs | README

michaelharley-net-wa2rlv.txt (14005B)


      1 [1]Skip to content [2]michaelharley.net [3](Menu) [≡] [×]
      2 
      3   • [4][A]boutAbout
      4   • [5][C]ontactContact
      5   • [6][P]ostsPosts
      6   • [7][S]itemapSitemap
      7 
      8 [8](Toggle light and dark theme) [9](Switch site skin) [10](Toggle modem-light
      9 animation)
     10 
     11 I own my books
     12 
     13 July 16, 2026 4 min read
     14 
     15 [11]Permalink
     16 
     17 I love reading. I caught the bug as a middle-schooler when I got caught
     18 skipping school, and as punishment, I had to read [12]The Chronicles of Amber
     19 (opens in a new tab) and do a book report about it. Even today, opening a book
     20 and fanning the pages to get the paper smell activates very fond memories and
     21 emotions.
     22 
     23 I remember a time before e-readers came out. I always thought reading on one
     24 seemed very futuristic. In military sci-fi books, characters are reading on
     25 their data pads, and reading on an e-reader makes me feel like a sci-fi
     26 character.
     27 
     28 Physically, e-readers are superior in every way to paper books. I can increase
     29 the font size. I can increase brightness. I can read in the sun. I can read in
     30 the pool. My entire library fits into my pocket. I can look up the definitions
     31 of words.
     32 
     33 Capitalists really hate when consumers love something, so of course they want
     34 to ruin e-readers. They do that by implementing digital rights management
     35 (DRM), and making people agree to draconian agreements such that the books they
     36 "buy" are in fact just renting. They want to lock you into their device
     37 ecosystem and force you to buy their hardware. That makes it very hard for
     38 consumers to buy a device from a different manufacturer as they basically have
     39 to abandon their digital libraries to do so.
     40 
     41 All that to say, I can understand why some people just do not want to deal with
     42 fighting with e-reader companies like Amazon so they might prefer paper books.
     43 I am up for the challenge though, and here is how I avoid the obstacles and
     44 hurdles that these companies put in the path to consumer choice and freedom.
     45 
     46 Removing DRM [13]#
     47 
     48 The most important thing to ebook freedom is removing the DRM the companies put
     49 on the books. I wrote about [14]how I remove DRM for backup purposes so I won't
     50 rehash that here, but the main thing is buying your ebooks from a distributor
     51 other than Amazon. I buy mine from [15]eBooks.com (opens in a new tab) and [16]
     52 Kobo.com (opens in a new tab) as they distribute their books with Adobe DRM,
     53 which the right tools can remove.
     54 
     55 I do not remove DRM so I can give my books away. I remove DRM so I have a
     56 backup of the books I paid for.
     57 
     58 This isn't paranoia. In 2019, [17]Microsoft shut down its ebook store (opens in
     59 a new tab), and because the books were DRM'd, every book every customer had
     60 ever bought simply stopped opening when the DRM servers went dark. Microsoft
     61 refunded everyone, which is a tidy admission that those were never really
     62 sales. A decade earlier, [18]Amazon reached into people's Kindles and deleted
     63 copies of 1984 (opens in a new tab) that they had already paid for, taking one
     64 [19]student's homework notes (opens in a new tab) along with the book. Not
     65 great, Bob.
     66 
     67 So I backup my books to an open standard, [20]ePUB (opens in a new tab), with
     68 the DRM stripped off. If eBooks.com folds tomorrow, or Kobo decides my account
     69 is a problem, or I want to read on hardware nobody has invented yet, my library
     70 still works.
     71 
     72 I don't care what their fine print says. I bought this book. It's my book. I'll
     73 read it where I like, TYVM.
     74 
     75 But what about Amazon exclusives? [21]#
     76 
     77 I want to support authors. I do not want to support anti-consumer choice
     78 cartels by giving them money.
     79 
     80 I remember back when Amazon first started, and they allowed smaller authors to
     81 self-publish their books. Back then, Amazon was the small guy, and it allowed
     82 other small guys to avoid the big book publishers. That was a right and good
     83 thing.
     84 
     85 But now, Amazon locks its exclusives behind the superior Amazon DRM and I don't
     86 know how to create DRM-free backups with the tools I have access to. So in the
     87 rare instance that I must purchase a book from Amazon, then I'll hold my nose
     88 and give Jeff Bezos my money. What happens after that, and how the book ends up
     89 readable on my Kobo, is left as an exercise for the reader.
     90 
     91 Audiobooks [22]#
     92 
     93 The same fight plays out with audiobooks, except here the landscape is still
     94 favorable to the consumer. My preference is [23]Libro.fm (opens in a new tab),
     95 who sells audiobooks DRM-free from the start. And you can strip even Audible's
     96 DRM, so nothing I buy is ever really locked inside their app.
     97 
     98 Same rule as my books: I paid for it, so I keep a copy I control. The medium
     99 changes; the principle doesn't.
    100 
    101 I'll sign off this post with a quote.
    102 
    103     Any time someone puts a lock on something that belongs to you and won't
    104     give you the key, that lock isn't there for your benefit.
    105 
    106     Cory Doctorow, [24]Information Doesn't Want to Be Free (opens in a new tab)
    107 
    108 Michael Harley Michael Harley [25]Author
    109 Filed under: [26]Books [27]Calibre [28]eBooks
    110 
    111 Also on [29]Mastodon (opens in a new tab) [30]Bluesky (opens in a new tab)
    112 
    113 You may also like
    114 
    115   • [31]How to setup Calibre to remove DRM from ebooks on Linux January 10,
    116     2023
    117   • [32]How I self-host my ebooks and audiobooks July 21, 2026
    118   • [33]On ebook readers and why I am opting out of vendor lock-ins March 09,
    119     2022
    120 
    121 Signal
    122 
    123 [34](Like this post) like
    124 21 likes
    125 
    126   • [35] TheNovemberFella ✊🏳️‍🌈 🇺🇦☸️🛰️🚀
    127   • [36] PurpleJillybeans :PrideDisk:
    128   • [37] Ronsboy67
    129   • [38] Alexander Corby 🇵🇷
    130   • [39] BookShelves eBook Reader
    131   • [40] Feral 3D
    132   • [41] Wojtek Powiertowski
    133   • [42] Pablonius Monk 🇺🇦
    134   • [43] Jeremy
    135   • [44] Kᑐᑌᑐᕮ
    136   • [45] Nick East (Indie Writer)
    137   • [46] richlinville.bsky.social
    138   • [47] Kevin Gallant
    139   • [48] alex
    140   • [id]
    141   • [id]
    142   • [id]
    143   • [id]
    144   • [id]
    145   • [id]
    146   • [id]
    147 
    148 4 boosts
    149 
    150   • [49] Ronsboy67
    151   • [50] Pablonius Monk 🇺🇦
    152   • [51] Jeremy
    153   • [52] Kᑐᑌᑐᕮ
    154 
    155 1 mention
    156 
    157   • [53] Bubbles (opens in a new tab)
    158 
    159 [54] 34 votes on Bubbles 🫧 (opens in a new tab)
    160 
    161 3 Comments
    162 
    163 mloxton
    164 
    165 [55]mloxton (opens in a new tab) via Mastodon Jul 16, 2026
    166 
    167 [56]@michaelharley (opens in a new tab)
    168 
    169 I get all the points you make, but that same picture looks a lot different from
    170 the author's perspective.
    171 
    172 There is also a transaction issue with your argument.
    173 The price of a book may vary according to what rights come with it. Using
    174 fictional numbers for illustration.
    175 
    176 Full rights: $50,000
    177 Right to read forever on any device: $50
    178 Right to read on a specified device $5
    179 Right to read on a specified device for a specified time: $1
    180 
    181 A
    182 
    183 [57]Antonio Santos (opens in a new tab) via antoniosantos.io Jul 16, 2026
    184 
    185 I regret not taking a similar approach to Michael Harley sooner. I always
    186 thought it didn't matter if I bought my books on Apple Books, because I would
    187 always have an iPad to read them on, until I bought a Kindle and wished I could
    188 read my books on my Kindle.
    189 
    190 Somehow, I let myself fall into the same trap with my Kindle, and now I'm
    191 locked into reading my books on a Kindle (at least there's a Kindle app for
    192 iOS).
    193 
    194 Recently, I started thinking about where I buy my e-books from for the same
    195 reasons as Michael: I want to be able to take my books with me anywhere, and
    196 back them up in case the provider goes away. So now I try to find DRM-free
    197 alternatives, like buying e-books straight from the author, or shopping on
    198 DRM-free platforms. I haven't tried removing DRM from books yet, not sure if I
    199 want to go thru the hassle.
    200 
    201 I also started doing the same for movies. Instead of buying them digital, I
    202 started buying physical copies. Eventually, I might get a Blu-Ray R/W and make
    203 digital copies for myself.
    204 
    205 Kᑐᑌᑐᕮ
    206 
    207 [58]Kᑐᑌᑐᕮ (opens in a new tab) via Mastodon Jul 17, 2026
    208 
    209 [59]@michaelharley (opens in a new tab) re:
    210 > "So in the rare instance that I must purchase a book from Amazon, then I'll
    211 hold my nose and give Jeff Bezos my money."
    212 
    213 I have a different approach: i always buy the **physical** book (which supports
    214 the author more, than buying any e-book) and then i simply download the `.epub`
    215 for free from... that 1 library that provides almost all e-books for free 🤷🏼‍♂️
    216 
    217 Join the conversation
    218 
    219   • [60]Respond via email
    220   • Leave a comment
    221 
    222     Your email is never shown. It's only so I can reply, and comments are
    223     moderated before they appear.
    224 
    225     Name * [61][                    ] Email (optional, private)
    226     [62][                    ] Website (optional, sets your avatar from your
    227     h-card) [63][                    ]
    228 
    229     Supports basic Markdown (bold, italic, links, lists, quotes). It's rendered
    230     to HTML once the comment is approved.
    231 
    232                   [                    ]
    233                   [                    ]
    234                   [                    ]
    235     Comment * [64][                    ]
    236     Leave this field empty [65][                    ]
    237     [69]Post comment
    238     or comment as yourself
    239 
    240     Have your own website? Sign in with it via [70]IndieAuth (opens in a new
    241     tab) and your name and avatar are pulled from your h-card. Nothing to fill
    242     in.
    243 
    244     Website [71][                    ] [73] Sign in with your website
    245   • Send me a webmention
    246 
    247     Written a response on your own site? Paste the URL and I'll display it
    248     alongside the others once I verify it links back.
    249 
    250     Your post URL * [74][                    ] [76]Send webmention
    251 
    252 © Michael Harley. [77]CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.
    253 
    254   • [78] Subscribe
    255   • [79]Colophon
    256   • [80]Privacy
    257   • [81]Back to top
    258 
    259 [82] [83]IndieWeb Webring [84] 
    260 [85]Powered by Debian (opens in a new tab) [86]Get Firefox (opens in a new tab)
    261 [87]Internet Archive (opens in a new tab) [88]uBlock Origin (opens in a new
    262 tab) [89]Join the Fediverse (opens in a new tab) [90]Creative Commons BY-NC-SA
    263 4.0 (opens in a new tab) [91]I support the Right to Repair (opens in a new tab)
    264 [92]Home Assistant (opens in a new tab) [93]Proxmox (opens in a new tab) [94]
    265 Team Fortress (opens in a new tab) [95]Powered by AMD (opens in a new tab) [96]
    266 QuakeWorld (opens in a new tab) [97]Made with Eleventy (opens in a new tab)
    267 Piracy Now Catscape Button Devils
    268 
    269 You are visitor #027384
    270 
    271 [98](Close)× []
    272 
    273 References:
    274 
    275 [1] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/16/i-own-my-books/#main
    276 [2] https://michaelharley.net/
    277 [4] https://michaelharley.net/about/
    278 [5] https://michaelharley.net/contact/
    279 [6] https://michaelharley.net/posts/
    280 [7] https://michaelharley.net/sitemap/
    281 [11] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/16/i-own-my-books/
    282 [12] https://books.infosec.exchange/book/726/s/the-great-book-of-amber-the-chronicles-of-amber-1-10
    283 [13] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/16/i-own-my-books/#removing-drm
    284 [14] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2023/01/10/how-to-setup-calibre-to-remove-drm-from-ebooks-on-linux/
    285 [15] https://www.ebooks.com/
    286 [16] https://www.kobo.com/
    287 [17] https://www.npr.org/2019/07/07/739316746/microsoft-closes-the-book-on-its-e-library-erasing-all-user-content
    288 [18] https://www.npr.org/2009/07/24/106989048/amazons-1984-deletion-from-kindle-examined
    289 [19] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2009/07/amazon_kindles_lawsuit_for_del.html
    290 [20] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPUB
    291 [21] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/16/i-own-my-books/#but-what-about-amazon-exclusives
    292 [22] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/16/i-own-my-books/#audiobooks
    293 [23] https://libro.fm/
    294 [24] https://craphound.com/category/info/
    295 [25] https://michaelharley.net/
    296 [26] https://michaelharley.net/tags/books/
    297 [27] https://michaelharley.net/tags/calibre/
    298 [28] https://michaelharley.net/tags/ebooks/
    299 [29] https://infosec.exchange/@michaelharley/116929585834523848
    300 [30] https://bsky.app/profile/michaelharley.net/post/3mqr7fh4dup2c
    301 [31] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2023/01/10/how-to-setup-calibre-to-remove-drm-from-ebooks-on-linux/
    302 [32] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/21/how-i-self-host-my-ebooks-and-audiobooks/
    303 [33] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2022/03/09/on-ebook-readers-and-why-i-am-opting-out-of-vendor-lock-ins/
    304 [35] https://bookstodon.com/@TheNovemberMan
    305 [36] https://kind.social/@PurpleJillybeans
    306 [37] https://mas.to/@ronsboy67
    307 [38] https://indieauthors.social/@AlexCorby
    308 [39] https://mastodon.social/@getbookshelves
    309 [40] https://mastodon.social/@Feral_3D
    310 [41] https://mastodon.social/@wojtekpow
    311 [42] https://mastodon.social/@pabloniusmonk
    312 [43] https://polymaths.social/@jp
    313 [44] https://mastodon.social/@Kdude
    314 [45] https://mastodon.art/@NickEast_IndieWriter
    315 [46] https://bsky.app/profile/richlinville.bsky.social
    316 [47] https://bsky.app/profile/kevin-gallant.bsky.social
    317 [48] https://toot.meiyerlan.casa/@miln
    318 [49] https://mas.to/@ronsboy67
    319 [50] https://mastodon.social/@pabloniusmonk
    320 [51] https://polymaths.social/@jp
    321 [52] https://mastodon.social/@Kdude
    322 [53] https://social.bubbles.town/@bubbles/statuses/01KXNDMAAG8JNS4H3J2RZV6ASR
    323 [54] https://bubbles.town/entry/44749901
    324 [55] https://zeroes.ca/@mloxton/116929886829689114
    325 [56] https://infosec.exchange/@michaelharley
    326 [57] https://antoniosantos.io/re-i-own-my-books/
    327 [58] https://mastodon.social/@Kdude/116933566178280292
    328 [59] https://infosec.exchange/@michaelharley
    329 [60] mailto:[email protected]?subject=Re:%20I%20own%20my%20books
    330 [70] https://indieauth.net/
    331 [77] https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
    332 [78] https://michaelharley.net/subscribe/
    333 [79] https://michaelharley.net/colophon/
    334 [80] https://michaelharley.net/privacy/
    335 [81] https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/07/16/i-own-my-books/#top
    336 [82] https://xn--sr8hvo.ws/previous
    337 [83] https://xn--sr8hvo.ws/
    338 [84] https://xn--sr8hvo.ws/next
    339 [85] https://www.debian.org/
    340 [86] https://www.firefox.com/
    341 [87] https://archive.org/
    342 [88] https://ublockorigin.com/
    343 [89] https://jointhefediverse.net/
    344 [90] https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
    345 [91] https://www.repair.org/
    346 [92] https://www.home-assistant.io/
    347 [93] https://www.proxmox.com/
    348 [94] https://www.teamfortress.com/
    349 [95] https://www.amd.com/
    350 [96] https://www.quakeworld.nu/
    351 [97] https://www.11ty.dev/